What editors want

Orgtheory has an excellent post in which several editors of leading journals in sociology explain what is a good review for them. Worth reading in full; everything applies directly to political science.

A small excerpt:

In my experience as editor, a common complaint among reviewers is that authors have not clearly articulated their work’s core contribution to knowledge. Many readers of articles in scholarly journals may not be reading with an interest in the particular empirical case, but are reading instead for the general ideas or the work’s theoretical argument.

This is a point that I make all the time when I give feedback on PhD projects (not so much when doing reviews for journals), but somehow I have the impression that it does not come across the right way.

In related news, the American Economic Association is abandoning “double blind” peer review. Reviewers will know the identity of the authors (but not vice versa). It seems that Political Analysis has similar plans.

1 thought on “What editors want

  1. There might be significant epistemic differences between countries on the point that you underline: I am under the impression that, in France, formulating a core theoretical argument that addresses the previous literature is often secondary to the empirical component, which has a lot of value per se in a discipline that is strongly influenced by historical research.

    Not to say that the relationship to the literature is openly considered accessory (it is not), but in practice, it seems fine to limit oneself to a tiny segment of it, based on national, (sub-)disciplinary and local schools of thought. Again, this is only an impression based on selective reading from French political science journals.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s